Your business is bringing in revenue and your bills are getting paid, but how are you paying yourself as the owner?
For incorporated businesses in Alberta, the choices include a salary, dividends or a combination of both. Figuring out the right approach depends on your personal income needs and plans for the future, in addition to the tax consequences of each option.
It starts with your corporate tax planning, which is an ongoing approach that you should discuss with your accountant.
Let’s take a look at the 6 things to review with your accountant.
1. Understand the Difference Between Salary and Dividends in Canada
- A salary pays you for the work you do as an employee of your corporation.
- A dividend is a distribution you receive as a shareholder.
Both can provide personal income, but they have different effects on the company and your own finances.
This table shows the differences.
| Consideration | Salary | Taxable Dividends |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate tax treatment | Qualifying salary is generally deductible | Not deductible to the corporation |
| Personal income | Employment income | Dividend income |
| CPP contributions | Generally apply to pensionable employment | Do not apply to dividend income |
| New RRSP contribution room | Can generate room, subject to the rules and limits | Does not generate room |
| Type of slip | T4 | T5 |
Dividends are generally paid from after-tax corporate profits. Salary reduces corporate taxable income when it qualifies as a deductible expense. That difference is important when comparing the two approaches.
Keep in mind, this comparison is for an incorporated business. Sole proprietors do not pay themselves dividends from their business.
2. Compare Corporate and Personal Taxes Together
If you only look at your personal tax bill, you won’t get a complete picture. With dividends, the corporation has already borne tax on the profits being distributed. You then report dividend income personally, with the applicable gross-up and dividend tax credit.
Eligible and non-eligible dividends receive different tax treatment. See CRA’s dividend reporting for guidance.
Ask your accountant to compare the options using the same amount of corporate profit before owner compensation. The comparison should show:
- Corporate income tax
- Personal income tax
- Applicable employee and employer CPP contributions
- Cash available to you after those costs
- Funds remaining in the corporation
Your other personal income, applicable federal and Alberta tax rates, and the corporation’s tax position can change the result. An online calculation is only useful when its assumptions match your circumstances.
Also, the corporation’s ability to pay an eligible dividend depends on its status and relevant tax accounts. It is something to confirm before making the payment. CRA’s dividend reporting can provide direction about this.
3. Consider Your RRSP and CPP Plans
How you pay yourself can impact how you prepare for retirement. Salary is earned income for RRSP purposes and can generate contribution room for the following year (subject to limits). Dividends do not generate new RRSP room. However, receiving dividends does not prevent you from using contribution room you already have available.
Check your latest notice of assessment and discuss the amount with your accountant. Check out CRA’s RRSP guidelines for more details.
CPP is also a consideration. Where CPP applies to your salary, the corporation must account for both the employee and employer contributions. Those contributions form part of your CPP record. The applicable rules depend on factors such as age and pensionable earnings. For more information, see CRA’s payroll guidance.
Take into consideration how owner compensation fits into your retirement plan by assessing your savings, any other employment income and the amount you intend to invest personally.
4. Determine Whether the Business Can Support Your Pay
Before deciding how to pay yourself, figure out how much the business can actually afford. A healthy bank balance may include money that’s needed for upcoming payments (such as payroll, supplier invoices, loan payments and/or taxes). Taking out that money today can put pressure on the business next month.
A regular review of the business cash flow can help you establish a sustainable payment schedule and identify when it needs to change.
5. Test Compensation Options
There is value in comparing more than one compensation plan. Here are a few scenarios:
- An incorporated consultant who wants predictable monthly income and plans to build RRSP savings might consider salary as their best choice.
- Another owner may already receive employment income from another source and might have different retirement savings priorities. A salary vs. dividend analysis would give a better look at whether dividends are in their favour.
- Some owners use a combination of salary and dividends. The appropriate mix should follow a review of the actual numbers rather than a standard percentage applied to every business.
Ask your accountant to explain how each option affects your personal cash, corporate cash and longer-term goals. Revisit the comparison when personal and business circumstances change.
6. What to Coordinate Depending on the Approach
Once you have determined the best approach, make sure your records support it. Salary requires payroll calculations, remittances and reporting. Dividends require the necessary corporate documentation and applicable T5 reporting. Agree on who is responsible for each step and when the information needs to be ready.
Take a look at CRA’s T5 guide for dividend information.
Payments to family shareholders also need a separate review. Tax on split income rules can apply to certain private company dividends, depending on the circumstances and available exclusions. CRA offers information on tax on split income.
Crescendo’s payroll accounting services can help connect your compensation plan with the reporting and ongoing administration it requires.
Schedule a Consultation
A business owner’s compensation should support their personal needs and the future of their business. At Crescendo Accounting, we help Calgary business owners connect corporate tax planning, payroll and financial reporting. We can review your current approach and help you understand how salary, dividends or a combination of both could fit your circumstances.
Schedule a consultation with Crescendo Accounting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I pay myself both salary and dividends?
Yes. An incorporated owner can receive both as long as the payments are appropriate and correctly reported. The amounts should be coordinated with the corporation’s financial position and your personal tax planning.
Are dividends better than getting a salary?
There is no single right answer. By comparing combined corporate and personal costs along with retirement goals, you can make a better decision. Remember that circumstances can change what was once a suitable approach.
Are dividends and drawings the same thing?
No. Drawings refer to money an owner takes out of the business, but the term does not establish the tax treatment. For a corporation, an owner withdrawal needs to be reviewed and recorded appropriately; it is not automatically a dividend.